Scoop and Dump Method of Soil Remediation – Summary

Background:

Over a 12-year period, the Scoop and Dump method of soil remediation was developed by the Urban Horticulture Institute at Cornell University with the goal of improving plant growth and soil health in managed landscapes. This technique of soil fracturing and incorporation of large quantities of compost was designed as a tool for the remediation of compacted and degraded soils in the urban environment.

 

Purpose:

Soils in urban environments often experience conditions that can degrade their quality and their ability to foster quality plant growth. Typical attributes of soils found in urban landscapes include high bulk density, decreased microbial activity, reduced levels of organic matter, poor structure, low water holding capacity, decreased aggregate stability, and inadequate volume for root proliferation. The Scoop and Dump method of soil remediation is a technique for reclaiming or improving sites that exhibit these conditions by reconstructing the profile via fracturing and incorporation of organic matter. The goal of this technique is the modify the physical properties of the soil to support healthy plant growth.

 

 Procedure:

Determine desired depth of compost incorporation

  • Herbaceous plant beds recommended depth: 12 inches
  • Woody plant beds recommended depth: 18-24 inches

Determine required compost volume

  • Spread compost to an even depth across the entire site.
  • If turf is present apply compost on top of grass.

With a backhoe:

  • Soils are scooped to the desired depth and lifted into the air.
  • Bucket is opened and soils are dropped back to the ground
  • If necessary, use the backhoe bucket to smooth over soils to create a somewhat even surface

Apply 2-4 inches of finished wood chip mulch after planting. Renew annually until canopy closure is achieved.

back hoe scooping and dumping
Backhoe scooping and dumping.

 

Amendment Considerations:

The primary factor to consider for determining how much compost to apply when amending soils is the resident soils texture. Different soil textures require different quantities of compost by volume to improve soil quality.

Resident Soil Texture Compost recommended by volume Post amendment

Bulk Density

(g/cm3)

Root Limiting Bulk Density

(g/cm3)

Sandy Loam –

compacted

33% <1.30 1.70
Clay Loam –

compacted

50% <1.20 1.55

 

Amendment Depth Compost required (cubic foot)
4 inches (10cm) 330
6 inches (15 cm) 500
8 inches (20cm) 661

* Recommended soil quantity for amending approximately a 1000 sq. ft bed

 

Compost Specifications:

Use a mature, stable, humus-like and aerobically decomposed compost derived from a known feedstock, and aerobically decomposed that has been tested to ensure quality. Composts should be a dark brown to black color and be capable of supporting plant growth in conjunction with appropriate management practices. Composts should have no visible free water, dust, or unpleasant odor. Composts should meet the following criteria as reported by laboratory tests. Recommended test methodologies are provided in Test Methods for the Examination of Composting and Compost (TMECC) from the United States Composting Council (USCC).

Parameters Recommended Ranges Units
pH 6.0 – 8.2
C:N 10 – 20 ratio
Organic Matter >24 % dry matter
Soluble Salts 1.0 – 3.5 mmhos/cm
Total N 0.5 – 3.5 % dry matter
NO3-N 100 – 1,000 mg/kg
NH4-N <500 mg/kg
NH4:NO3 <10
P2O5 <1.0 % dry matter
K20 1.0 – 3.0 % dry matter
Particle Size 100% passing through 3 cm sieve
85% passing through 2 cm sieve
40-60% passing through 2mm sieve
% dry matter