Last Thursday, I attended a “Be the Change” pre-engagement workshop through Engaged Cornell as a Training session for Rose Service Scholars. There were two specific parts of the workshop that stood out, one being an article we read called “Helping, Fixing, or Serving?” and the other being a satirical video of a young woman who goes to “Africa” to “help” for social media purposes. Both elements were riveting in their own sense, the article resonating deeply with me as an individual and the video disturbing me as a fellow human being.
The article made a distinction between “helping” a community or trying to “fix” their problems as an outsider (in a superior standing) and “serving” that community as a fellow human being (in an equal standing). Many times, we make the mistake of assuming that a certain community needs our help and rather than initiating conversations and asking said community what their needs are, how they would like to be helped, what role they would like us take, we insert ourselves with authority in said community and enforce what we think needs to be done and address the needs we perceive as important. It’s not something that we necessarily do with ill intentions or with our hearts in the wrong place, we just haven’t been taught, haven’t learned to serve others in this way rather than help and fix them the way we deem correct. By serving, we recognize others as fellow humans and recognize the work we are doing as a gift, to them and ourselves. We create human connection and serve each other in humility, rather than fulfilling some sort of charitable quota under a philanthropic or humanitarian pretense (not that there’s anything wrong with such endeavors, but the intention and action need to come from more than perhaps a mere sense of duty or obligation).
The video emphasized this as it showed a young woman, who with the wrong intentions, headed to the “real” Africa (apparently the entire continent), where poverty and sickness was displayed everywhere she looked. She took a plethora of photos, handed out candy, and “helped” out in a school and hospital. So many things were wrong with the video that it was difficult to muster up enough effort to even talk about how awful it was. She went to “help” a community (a whole continent) with stereotypical pretenses, did not make an effort to engage with said community and ask what it was exactly that they needed, she took pictures at highly inappropriate times, was inconsiderate of all those in need around her, was ignorant in what she posted and how she captioned it, and wrongfully fed supposedly starving children candy bars. Not once did we see her spend time with, bond, or form a personal connection with anyone on her trip. Not only did she hurt the community by her “help,” but she violated the community as a whole by intruding into their space without being asked (or even without asking herself). She did not come to humbly engage with or to serve the community, but to impose her “goodwill” and “charity” upon them, since they “obviously needed” it and she was “in the power” to “grant” it.
We need to remember that we are on equal standing when we are serving a community that is not our own– our aim is not to do what we would like or think is correct, but to honor what said community has shared (their needs and wants) during our engaging with them as fellow human beings. Serving others can be a wonderful opportunity for creating personal connections as well as a time that can bring the community and ourselves fulfillment. I count it a grand blessing to return to serve BJM with a mindset that has been refreshed and renewed by these crucial elements of Community Engagement.