The Accomplishment of Gender

I’ve watch Fight Club numerous times. It’s one of those movies where you always find something new. The first time I watched Fight Club, I didn’t notice any of the tricks in the cinematography or any other nuances. The second time over, I started to notice hints early on in the movie that Edward Norton’s character (Now referred to as the Protagonist) had created an ‘alter ego’ named Tyler Durden. On this occasion, the movie’s portrayal of gender caught my attention.

By looking at the Protagonist’s pattern of behavior, it is clearly evident that Fight Club functions to ‘accomplish gender’. Initially, the Protagonist used to visit support groups, under the false pretense of being ill. The support groups were areas where the Protagonist could be emotional without fearing potential judgment from a society where crying may be viewed as a threat to manliness. Later on, the Protagonist stops going to support groups, and focuses on Fight Club instead.

Fight Club, is in itself a representation of toxic/hyper masculinity. During their meetings, members of Fight Club cheer on as two men fight until one taps out, conceding the other’s victory. Victory, in this sense, is neither cash nor a prize. Rather, these fights function as a proclamation of masculinity, in which the members may find catharsis.

In this way, the movie highlights how gender is a dynamic concept: something that can be ‘accomplished’ by actions and behavior. Another crucial aspect of gender is appearance. For example, Bob was a man who had developed breasts due to complications with testicular cancer. During one of the support group sessions, Bob says to the Protagonist that, ‘We’re still men’. For Bob, participating in Fight Club was a way to reclaim his masculinity while dealing with changes with his body.

There are countless other examples which could be linked to gender. Overall, this movie highlights the social construction of gender and the dangers that arise from trying to use a dichotomy to categorize human behavior.

2 thoughts on “The Accomplishment of Gender

  1. Hi, Sriya! Do you think the film was condemning the pervasiveness of toxic masculinity in American society? I don’t know how I feel about it myself. On one hand, Tyler Durden is portrayed as the antagonist, and the Narrator does succeed in defeating him, so it appears as if in the end he overcomes the toxic nature of hypermasculinity. On the other hand, I think not enough is done to deconstruct the enthralling image of Tyler Durden and Fight Club that Fincher develops earlier in the film. Durden is depicted as charismatic, savvy, and magnetic for the majority of Pitt’s screen time, and I think for most viewers it is this image of the character that leaves a lasting impression.

  2. I agree with you that one of the themes of Fight Club is to underline the social construction of gender. Through everyday actions, we perform our gender identities rather than expressing them. I find it interesting that you point out that even though Bob has testicular cancer and grow seemingly female attributes but still seek his identity as a man through support group. Moreover, I think the movie also goes beyond gender and alludes to the general construction of identity. For instance, the protagonist says that he wants to find the right furniture on IKEA catalog to represent him. In this case, identity is not something essential that one possess, but rather an act that one performs.