On Thursday, I had the opportunity to have dinner with two Board of Trustees members and two students at the Rose House dining hall. The two Board of Trustees members that we dined with were Lee and Yoon. They are alumni of Cornell University. After introducing ourselves and our career goals, they asked us questions about our opinions on legacy and athletic scholarships. The reason was that they wanted to discuss the notorious college admissions scandal with us. The student on my left said that he has no problem with legacy being factored into the admissions process, but he said that legacy should not be the bulk of the applicant’s profile. I agree with his statement because an applicant’s GPA, test scores, extracurricular activities, personal statements, supplements, and recommendation letters should be given more weight than legacy. Legacy means an applicant’s parent or parents graduated from the university that the applicant is applying to. To be honest, I believe legacy serves the same purpose as diversity, ethnicity, and religious background. They are just background information that the college or university asks for to admit a diverse number of applicants.
As for athletic scholarships, I agree with Anthony, the student on my right, who said that if student athletes can contribute to the school by winning games and earning recognition, they deserve to attend the school with scholarships. I understand that the issue with college admissions is reserving spots for the rich and athletes because those spots could be given to low-income, first-generation students. I do think that is an issue because it may seem like the privileged people get more opportunities, while the underprivileged people get fewer opportunities. However, I believe that if an applicant shows the potential to succeed in a prestigious university based on the criteria and shares a genuine story, he or she should be admitted regardless of family income and legacy. I also believe that student athletes should be on scholarships because it is not easy to balance academics and practices. There is a policy for student athletes to maintain a certain GPA so that their scholarships do not get revoked. Thus, I enjoyed discussing these topics with the Board of Trustees members and my peers while eating dinner.