1: INDUSTRY OVERVIEW: DEPARTMENT STORES
Department stores are large retail outlets that contain numerous individual shops, providing a wide range of product lines. Department stores most oftentimes consist of the following product categories:
1) Food
2) Cosmetics
3) Shoes and Accessories
4) Clothing
5) Interior Décor
6) Restaurants
Depending on the type of department store, department stores can offer a much wider range of products, including furniture, toys, electronics, books, etc.
Department stores come in a wide range of qualities and prices. There are such things as “high-end department stores”, which would focus purely on offering high-profile brands and products, while there are more mass-market targeting department stores, which are more likely to include a wider range of products, including practical household products.
That said, department stores will oftentimes try to cater to specific types of market segments. Particularly in the case of department stores in large cities, each department store will try to position itself differently from its direct and nearby competitors: some will try to cater to younger generations, while some will try to cater to the older generations. Some will try to cater to those interested in mainstream brands, while others will focus more on boutique, independent brands.
In the US, the department store industry includes approximately 20 companies operating roughly 3,500 stores. Major department stores in the US include: Sears, JCPenney, Macy’s, and Dillard’s. The industry earns an annual revenue of around $60 billion USD, 95% of which is earned by the largest 8 companies in the industry.
Some links about the industry:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Department_store
http://vspages.com/mall-vs-department-store-5580/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shopping_mall
http://www.hoovers.com/industry/department-stores/1529-1.html
SPACE
2a: Implicit or Explicit?
From the department store owner’s standpoint, I would say that space is often sold explicitly, as they would charge the tenants per the size of the lease space. On the other hand, for stalls or booths set up in more open areas of the department store, space may be considered more implicit, as these spaces may be sold with less correlation to the exact size of the space.
2b: Ways of Splitting Space
Department stores have different types of spaces within the building that cater to their customers. The most typical type is the space split by fixed walls into one unit, and can usually be shut off or closed by a door or a shutter. These spaces cannot easily be adjusted in terms of size and layout without investment of significant time and money. These fixed spaces are generally leased out to a specific brand or company, such as Zara, Coach, Burberry, etc.
Then there is the semi-fixed space, such as the department store areas dedicated to selling cosmetics or shoes. These are oftentimes open areas in which a specific brand or merchandising line take up certain spaces, but are not divided up by physical walls or entryways. These areas are much more flexible in terms of changing the products being handled, given that one area can easily be changed to carry one brand/line from another; however, certain fixtures used for the displays will be fixed, and hence less flexible to change from a layout perspective.
There is also open space, in which temporary booths or stalls are built to sell a smaller line of products or services.
Different from other uses of store space is the use of space to purely focus on selling experiential services. For department stores, the focus generally remains on selling physical products. However, there are rare instances when space is allocated to selling services—one case being when department stores are attached to movie theaters.
2c: Creating Additional Revenue
One of the most standard ways for department stores to create additional revenue is by holding major seasonal sales. Because the product life cycle of clothes tends to be fairly short, many stores have inventory left over by the time they have to replace old products with new products. Having a highly publicized sale allows for these leftover products to be sold, be it at a lower price than its retail value.
One key to making people spend more money is to convince people to stay out shopping longer. A way to
do this is to provide adequate opportunity for people to take a break from shopping and rest. Many department stores provide these venues by creating food courts—or in high-end places by providing patisseries or coffee shops at which people can recharge before going back to shop some more.
I also think one of the more creative ways in which department stores have used their space to create additional revenue is through creative use of its open space. Another approach department stores can use to bring people to their stores is to provide an additional incentive to go to that location. A common approach used to achieve this in the U.S. has been to create playgrounds in the open areas of the department stores. This service often incentivizes families to go to a department store, simply because it allows an opportunity for their children to play.
One more approach commonly used in Japanese department stores to bring more people to the site is to host certain “festivals” or special events in their open space. For example, department stores would often host weekly “mini fairs” on either the ground floor or the top floor, in which one area of the department store would be devoted to hosting jewelry/clothes/food from brands and shops that usually were not represented at the department store. The content would be changed frequently, and the department store would often be able to bring new people into the store by publicizing new, limited-time genres of offerings at their store.
2d: Potential New Ways of Splitting Space
There are several different directions department stores could potentially go in terms of splitting space differently. One direction would be to use space to create more personalized services to customers. Many of the spaces in department stores are “public”, but allocating a portion of space at high-end stores to allow for “private” space may allow for varying experiences for customers. Customers would be charged a premium for making use of these private spaces.
Another potential use may be to make the spaces more flexible. Instead of sticking with a model that leans heavily toward having “fixed” spaces, changing to a model in which it would be much simpler, cheaper, and quicker to change tenants may be an attractive approach for department stores that are pursuing a more trendy, up-to-date feel.
3: TIME
3a: Implicit or Explicit?
Department stores generally sell time implicitly: this is because the product being sold generally isn’t associated with a particular time limit. For example, it is not like a massage, where you are buying 60 minutes worth of service. The transaction is associated with a physical product unattached to time.
3c: Selling Time Explicitly
Time is currently being sold explicitly at certain department stores, although these cases are generally not a reflection of its overall business model. For example, some department stores may include shops that offer time-explicit services. Some department stores have massage shops, which are time-based service sales.
As another example, some department stores in Japan have small football fields on their rooftops, which people can rent out on an hourly basis.
(http://www.futaba-sp.com/omiya/2010/03/post-23.html)
Some department stores also include game centers for children—some of these entertainment options include machines that run for a set period of time per game.
Department stores will often have restaurants on one of their floors. These restaurants can often choose to set time limits to each group of customers (ex. 2hr limit) to be able to take in more customers during peak times.
(http://www.mitokeisei.co.jp/shop/10_skygarden/11keizan.html)
3d: Creative Things to do with Time
There are a couple things that could be done creatively with time—some of which may already be being done to varying lengths at department stores. One might be to offer some sort of benefit if a certain amount of time is spent within the department store. For example, if a customer was to receive certain benefits if they stayed for 5 hours at a department store on an off-peak day, this could incentivize customers to spend more money during their wait time, and this could also help to improve the image of the department store by maintaining more customers.
Another thing they might potentially consider doing is to include shops that provide rental services. Some shops may already do tuxedo/dress rentals, which would be time-based; they could potentially take this further by doing time-based rentals of other high-end luxury clothes and accessories.
4a/b: Physical and Non-Physical Rate Fences
Below are several examples of physical rate fences (owner-tenant relationships are more likely to be involved with physical rate fences than the tenant-customer relationships)
- (Owner-tenant POV) Depending on the size of the space being rented, owners can choose to increase or decrease the rates
- (Owner-tenant POV) Certain areas of a department store are likely to be more popular/convenient; hence an owner can charge more depending on the location of the space within the store (http://www.ehow.com/facts_6313023_average-retail-lease_.html)
- (Tenant-customer POV) For services such as restaurants within the department store, tenants can set rates by charging differently between open areas and private rooms
In terms of non-physical rate fences, I would say that there are many opportunities to create rate fences, depending on the type of service/product the store sells. There are also several opportunities within the owner-tenant relationship:
- (Owner-tenant POV) Depending on the lease period, the owner can set different rates to charge the tenant
- (Owner-tenant POV) Depending on the credibility/attractiveness of the tenant, the owner can set different rates
- (Tenant-customer POV) Depending on the quality of the product, functionality of the product, or time/length of the service, rates can be set differently. There is an enormously wide range of examples of this in department stores. A Gap outlet, for example, may sell a tank top for $10, while a Burberry outlet would sell a similar styled tank top for $150. Similarly, a cell phone with 3G functionality may sell at a cell phone provider outlet at a certain price, while a phone with 4G functionality would sell at a much higher price.
4c: Creative Ways to Set Rate Fences
Some ways I can think of setting rate fences creatively is to perhaps offer more intangible services—rather than just the physical products. For example, an I Love Bangkok t-shirt may only cost $5 at the actual retail shop, but if the customer already knows what he/she wants, but doesn’t want to make the trip up 7 floors and 5 minutes of walking to get there, the store could potentially charge an extra $1 to have the t-shirt brought down to the concierge desk of the department store for a quick pick-up.
learn more
ach cancer in chronic gastritis.
Poria cocos (Fuling), a natural plant, has recently emerged as a promising strategy for cancer treatment. However, the molecular mechanisms of Poria cocos action in breast cancer remain poorly understood.
TCMSP database was used to screen the potential active ingredients in Poria cocos. GEO database was used to identify differentially expressed genes
Ethanol fireplace wall mount
Wall Mounted Bio Ethanol Fireplace Reviews
Ethanol fireplaces provide a clean, effective option to standard wood burning fires. They also need no chimney or flue and can be installed anywhere. They come in a range of sizes, from little tabletop designs to cocoon-style wall units.
Although these fireplaces
emergency gas engineer buckingham
The Legal Requirement For Landlords To Bring Out A Yearly Gas Safety Check
If you’re a landlord you have a legal obligation to make sure that gas home appliances, pipe work and flues are maintained in a safe condition. This includes yearly safety checks.
Landlords can not move the task to their renter if they sub-let their residential or commercial
click here
Several biomarkers predict the efficacy of immunotherapy, which is essential for selecting patients who would potentially benefit. Discordant status of these biomarkers between primary tumours and paired metastases has been increasingly revealed. We aimed to comprehensively summarize the incidence of this phenomenon.
Databases were searched to identify studies reporting primary-to
registrierten führerschein kaufen ohne anzahlung
Buy a Driving License Without Paying in Advance
It should be brief and directly connected to the main topic of your article. It should be brief and directly relevant to the main subject of your article.
When renewing your driver’s license
web tasarım
Kreatif bir web site layihamı ise bu medarımaişetin çekirdeği olmakla omuz omuza, sizin bu kesime ulaşabilmenize fayda sağlamlayacak en davranışlevsel anahtardır.
5- Web tasarım sürecinde ve üretiminde web düşüncem estetiği ve numerik nitelik şemasılarını kavramak
Tarayıcınızın ayarlarını kötüdaki tablodan müteallik link’e tıklayarak değhi
PTC-209
ulates the antioxidant capacity is compromised. In this context, redox imbalance takes place, resulting in oxidative damage to both lipids (70%, p less then 0.001) and proteins (140%, p less then 0.001). These results suggest that glaucoma damages not only eye structures but also brain visual targets such as the primary visual cortex. Redox imbalance takes place due to an enhancement in ROS and reactive nitrogen species pro
tempat camping di lembang bandung
Saat memiliki rencana petualangan camping, memilih pakaian yang pas jadi tidak benar satu hal terpenting yang mesti diperhatikan. Cuaca yang berubah-ubah dan bermacam aktivitas luar ruang menuntut kami untuk menggunakan baju yang tidak hanya nyaman, namun terhitung stylish. Terutama jika kamu mengambil keputusan untuk menjelajahi tempat
click through the next site
Choosing a Range Dual Fuel Cooker
A dual fuel range can increase the value of your home and make entertaining a breeze. Installed by a professional, it requires a gas outlet and a power outlet.
The experts from the Good Housekeeping Institute’s Kitchen Appliances and Innov
potentstream buy
As men age, keeping prostate health turns into increasingly important for overall well-being. Prostate issues can result in discomfort, frequent trips to the bathroom, and a diminished quality associated with life. PotentStream, the revolutionary prostate product, is here to offer the best solution every man needs for ideal prostate health.
What is PotentStream?
PotentStream is actu
rindubola daftar
Rindubola is a well-liked online platform offering many different services, which includes gaming, entertainment, in addition to more. For customers who are brand-new or are looking to sign in to be able to Rindubola, understanding the logon process is vital intended for accessing the platform’s full range involving features. Whether a person are planning to play online games, take full advantage of promotions, or explore the services present
click the up coming post
Buy a C1 Certificate to Improve Your Chances of a Higher Education Scholarship
A person with C1 English level is able to function independently in the majority of situations. They are able to comprehend a variety of texts even those that are longer and more demanding. They also can express themselves effortlessly and in a natural way, thanks to the controlled use of connectors, organizationa
Driving Instructor Training
Buy Driving License Category B Online
There are a variety of websites that let you buy driving license category B. These driving licenses could be genuine or fake. Select a site with a good reputation and provides secure payment methods.
Generally, you will continue be licens
Mubritinib mw
A general method was developed for preparing a metal-organic framework-polymer composite coated silica core-shell stationary phase. Silica microspheres were comodified with metal-organic framework and polyvinylpyrrolidone rather than the in situ method of silica modification by original metal-organic framework particles. Metal-organic framework particles and polyvinylpyrrolidone on silica surface were benef
sunwin
I loaded my account and decide to hit up the Live Baccarat tables. I wasn’t disgruntled. If you’re new to Baccarat it’s the sport James Bond plays and also that know it’s cool. Online game itself is real simple: Two cards are dealt to two hands, named Player and Banker. Hand calculators bet on the Player, Banker, Tie or any combination of the back yard garden. The object of the g
IDN-6556 research buy
To investigate the monocyte-to-HDL-cholesterol ratio (MHR), neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio (NLR), platelet-to-lymphocyte ratio (PLR), lymphocyte-to-monocyte ratio (LMR), eosinophil-to-lymphocytes ratio (ELR), platelet distribution width (PDW), red blood cell distribution width (RDW), mean platelet volume (MPV), MPV to platelet count ratio (MPV/PC), and RDW to platelet ratio (RPR) that ar
ABT-199 nmr
Surgeons make important contributions to basic science research and are in a unique position to innovate scientifically. The number of surgeons pursuing basic science research has been declining over the past two decades. We sought to describe perceived barriers to surgeons’ pursuit of basic science research and identify interventions that mitigate these obstacles.
An online surve
cheap woodburner
How Much Room Do You Have For a Small Wood Burning Stove?
Wood stoves are beloved by many for their warm atmosphere and the process of building an fire. But, there are a few things to be aware of when selecting the ideal small wood stove for your space.
You may, for instance,
What Is the very best Fridge Freezer Brand Name?
We asked specialists and validated purchasers to nominate their favored fridge freezer brands . We considered their credibilities for dependability and owner fulfillment, along with their features, price varieties, energy performance ratings, and customer support options.
<br
https://checkpoint-games.com/
Checkpoint-Games.com sudah jadi satu diantara web-site yang mengundang perhatian banyak pengagum permainan online. Basis ini menjajakan bermacam spek dan service yang didesain untuk berikan pengalaman bermain game yang heboh serta mengesankan. Dari kumpulan beberapa game yang luas sampai spesifikasi populasi yang dalam, Checkpoint-Games.com berusaha guna penuhi keperluan tiap pemain. berikut bakal membahas dengan cara je
TGF-beta tumor
This present study finds the importance of PFK1 which can be worked as a novel target in NPC treatment and holds great potential to be extended to other malignant cancers.
To assess the concurrent validity and the diagnostic accuracy of the Acoustic Breathiness Index (ABI) in Brazilian Portuguese.
The counting numbers 1-20 and the vowel /a/ of 150 subjects were reco
슬롯사이트
온라인 카지노 사이트는 플레이어와 비디오 카지노 게임을 판매 및 운영하는 회사를 연결합니다.Choegocasino.com은 그러한 사이트 중 하나입니다. 처음 고객을 환영합니다.
choegocasino.com에서 영업 중이며 첫 번째 고객이 스트리밍 중입니다! 사이트는 슬롯, 블랙잭, 룰렛을 제공하며 이미 많은 수익을 창출하고 있습니다. 지금 어디에 있나요? 이제 choegocasino.com에 가입하여 수백만 달러의 수익을 창출할 수 있습니다.Choegocasino.com은 한국 최고의 온라인 카지노 중 하나가 되었습니다! , 블랙잭, 룰렛을 포함한 다양한 온라인 카지노 게임을 제공하며 이미 매월 수백만 명의 방문자를 끌어 모으고 있습니다. 그럼 무엇을 기다리고 계십니까? 지금 빅빅과 함께하세요!
<
company information details
Evaluate monetary situation. Find out where the debt is of and compare it inside your present financial income. Put it all recorded on paper make an objective decision by the results.
The difference between a “merger” in addition to an “acquisition” (M&A) has become increasingly blurred over the years. This is due in
Terephthalic
Atherosclerosis is a multifactorial disease influenced by genetics, lifestyle and environmental factors. Despite therapeutic advances that reduce the risk of cardiovascular events, atherosclerosis-related diseases remain the leading cause of mortality worldwide. Precise targeting of genes involved in lipoprotein metabolism is an emerging approach for atherosclerosis prevention and treatment. This article foc
leather four seater sofa
4 Seater Leather Couch
A good 4 seater leather couch can be a perfect match for many different styles of living room decor. You can utilize dark hues to contrast white sofas, or you can match the colour of your furniture to your wall artwork and accents.
<br
large bedside cot
Newborn Bedside Cot
A newborn bedside cot is a small sleeper that allows newborns to sleep in the same room as their parents, without the dangers of co-sleeping (which the AAP cautions against due suffocation and SIDS). It also makes nursing sessions and care much easier.
This sleeper features a firm mattress that is designed to support babies’ backs
wood burning stoves ideas
What You Need to Know About Outdoor Wood Burners
Outdoor wood burners are an economical solution to heat homes and businesses. They also reduce the dependence on fossil fuels that are non-renewable and contribute to a resilient energy strategy.
Wood that is well-seasoned is crucial for efficient b
14 Savvy Ways To Spend Extra Genuine Bmw Replacement Key Budget bmw keyless entry,
Ava,
Rimiducid mw
Lung diseases, such as pulmonary hypertension and pulmonary fibrosis, are life-threatening diseases and have common features of vascular remodeling. During progression, extracellular matrix protein deposition and dysregulation of proteolytic enzymes occurs, which results in vascular stiffness and dysfunction. Although vasodilators or anti-fibrotic therapy have been mainly used as therapy owing to these charact
Selleckchem Bcl-2 inhibitor
The implementation of nursing clinical learning in Indonesia has several challenges that require innovation in the learning method strategy. The method that has been used so far focuses on the hierarchical relationship between lecturers/preceptors and students, so that there are many shortcomings in learning outcomes. The application of the method of active learning with Peer Learning (PL) and Problem Based Learnin
Selleck DRB18
ention. It warrants greater attention as an early warning sign of deterioration, and low-burden, user-friendly digital tools may play a role in its early detection.
This study was performed on fresh frozen cadavers to investigate the role of angular artery damage.
Lateral osteotomies (‘high-low-high’ method) were carried out bilaterally, with a 4 mm guarded lat
3′,3′-cGAMP
Diabetes management mainly includes lifestyle intervention (including diet, exercise, weight loss, etc.), anti-hyperglycemia therapy (including drugs and insulin), blood glucose monitoring, and hypoglycemic prevention. In addition, specific clinical recommendations are given to patients with special health care needs such as diabetic nephropathy, elderly (>75 years), and cardiovascular critical illness.Pulmonary ar
see more
0 ± 3.0 and 6.8 ± 0.7 μM, respectively. The inhibition of papain by mycotoxins (fusaric acid and beauvericin) may indicate a mechanism of Fusarium in the roles of infection process.PURPOSE To assess the diagnostic value of multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) in small bowel obstruction (SBO) patients. METHODS Relevant literature was searched from the Cochrane Library, Pubmed and Embase. The extracted effective data was calcula
buy MLN7243
More research is needed to evaluate safe outpatient options, induction methods in the setting of prior cesarean with an unfavorable cervix, and to directly compare misoprostol with oxytocin as adjuncts to transcervical balloons.It is commonly assumed that beneficial adaptations in bone occur with vigorous exercise, yet any adaptive re/modeling in bone undergoing persistent overloading can be counteracted by super
Betone電子游戲，Betone老虎機，Betone捕魚機，Betone真人
玩法介紹
花旗骰，又稱Sic Bo，是一種源自中國的傳統骰子遊戲，廣受玩家歡迎。beitone提供的花旗骰遊戲界面簡潔明瞭，設計旨在為玩家帶來純正的遊戲體驗。 Betone電子游戲，Betone老虎機，Betone捕魚機，Betone真人 。
投注方式
大小
小：骰子點數總和為4到10。
大：骰子點數總和為11到17。
注意，出現三個相同點數（即豹子）時，大小投注均為輸。
<
PIN1inhibitorAPI1
alues and accordingly should only be used sparingly.Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium) causes gastroenteritis in many countries. However, in Brazil there are few studies that have conducted a virulence characterization of this serovar. The aim of this study was to evaluate the virulence potential of S. Typhimurium strains isolated in Brazil. Forty S. Typhimurium s
SB225002 supplier
Other strategies aim at improving gastric emptying in PD patients, primarily including prokinetic agents.Purpose To evaluate the efficacy of topical ivermectin-metronidazole combined therapy in the management of Demodex-associatedblepharitis. Methods Sixty patients with a diagnosis of Demodex-associatedblepharitis were recruited in a randomized clinical trial. Thirty receiving topical ivermectin (0.1%)-metronidaz
learn more
Zebrafish has emerged as a potential animal model of acute convulsion for early screening of antiepileptic agents. There is a need for alternative chronic zebrafish models of epilepsy with more correlation to the clinical condition.
Adult zebrafish were repeatedly exposed to subeffective concentrations of pentylenetetrazole (PTZ), until appearance to tonic-clonic seizures, conside
this article
Wood Burning Stoves Ideas
A wood stove adds warmth and natural charm to your home. They can also save you money and reduce emissions.
With the appropriate surround and accessories, an elegant log burner can be a feature that stands out. It can also be a subtle shade such as
The Reasons Why Asbestos Cancer Law Lawyer Mesothelioma Settlement Is
Everyone’s Passion In 2023 mesothelioma Attorneys
Dai ly nuoc Minh Tue Water
Chuyen cung cap nuoc dong binh, dong chai cac thuong hieu Vinh Hao, Lavie, Aquafina, TH Pro…
postheaven.net/cuathepvangothaibinh/minh-tue-water-chuyen-cung-cap-nuoc-dong-binh-dong-chai-chat-luong-tai-tp-hcm : 716 duong La Xuan Oai, phuong Long Truong, Quan 9, TP HCM
Dien thoai: 0828.580.580
<b
https://functionrate.com/
Keuntungan dalam taruhan judi online pastinya bervariasi. Sampai di dalam masalah tersebut beberapa bettor dapat tingkatkan kesempatan keuntungan banyak. Dalam soal tingkatkan keuntungan taruhan judi karena itu terdapat beberapa soal yang dapat dikerjakan. Kalau saja ide dalam taruhan dikerjakan secara benar maka dapat membesarkan kesempatan keuntungan.
Kenali secara bagus berkaitan rencana serta tata langkah
visit the following web site
Choosing the Best Wood Burning Stove
Wood stoves require a significant investment in time and money. It is also important to consider the winter conditions in your area and be sure to follow local rules on wood and fire.
A wood stove that is too small will cause you to shiver under
sunwin
Most, assure all internet casinos will offer all within the major games of chance, such as; poker, craps, roulette, slots, and pontoon. Therefore, on your initial visit along with casino weight are not healthy to totally review most of the different games that offer you.
It may appear far more cost effective: for one, most online casino s work with such
Driving Instructor Training
Cheap Driving Lessons in Scunthorpe
It can change your life. It gives you independence, and allow you to take your time and travel at your own pace rather than waiting for your family or friends to pick you up.
Darren Rush Driving Tuition offers affordable and professi
In this text
What is freelancing?
Why develop into a freelancer?
What instruments do I have to generate income freelancing?
Driving Lessons Scunthorpe
Buy Ireland Drivers License and International Driving Permits
With numerous tests and appointments to make, obtaining the right to drive in Ireland can be a daunting process. But, it doesn’t have to be.
If you hold a current licence issued by an acknowledged state, you
Blebbistatin ic50
0001) as compared with healthy volunteers. A higher correlation (R2 = 0.8922) was found between deep white matter hyperintensities’ size and blood lead levels. In nutshell, persistence of high blood lead level in diabetic patients may progress to brain hyperintensities which may consequently lead to cognitive, behavioral changes and Alzheimer’s disease.Excess fluoride intake has been linked with various patho
MK-8617 in vitro
8% (base model) to 57.8% (Step 1). However, setting physiological parameters (liver blood flow determined by magnetic resonance imaging, glomerular filtration rate, hematocrit) to measured values in the second step did not further improve the simulation result (59.1% in the 1.25-fold range). In the third step, virtual twins matching individual demography, physiology, and CYP1A2 activity considerably improved the si
selleck products
01). Different alleles and genotypes of the genes under study were detected. Short interspersed nuclear element (SINE) -/- genotype of FSHβ revealed significantly higher litter traits (p less then .05, LSB p less then .01). The LWW was also found to be significantly influenced by ESR BB and AB, EGF AB and BB, and PRLR CC genotypes (p less then .05). Although we did not find statistically significant and consistently