And, notes from Mary Flanagan and Eric Paulos’ keynote and tutorial from the second day of the SoCS workshop. Mary first.
Not all games are serious games: critical games, causal games, art games, silly games — the question here is about how play and games interact. Or, even more basic, how do we know when people (or animals) are playing? Openness, non-threatening, relative safety, …
Instead, thinking about important elements of play might be a fruitful way to help designers (“Intro to game design 101” part of the talk). So, for instance, thinking about what people are looking for in meaningful play: meaning/context, choice/inquiry, action/agency, outcomes/feedback, integration/experience, discernment/legibility. Or, thinking about ways to carve up the elements of the game itself: rules/mechanics, play/dynamics, and culture/meaning.
So, what does this mean if you want to design games with a purpose, that have social good or social commentary or social change as their goals? In particular, gamification has a connotation of making people do things, a la persuasive computing, that makes people who design games feel really awkward because play is generally voluntary. Are Girl Scout merit badges about “play”?
Buffalo: a game that juxtaposes pairs of words that requires people to give names that encompass both the words (“contemporary” “robot”; “female” “scientist”; “multiracial” “superhero”; “Hispanic” “lawyer”), and the group of players to agree that the names are appropriate. It’s designed to help us reflect on stereotypes and implicit biases, and increase or broaden our “social identity complexity” (ability to belong to/respect/know about multiple social groups).
Which is important, because apparently these kinds of biases and divisions show up really young. (Though, it makes you wonder how to design games — both practically and ethically — for the very young, to help address issues like that.) And, because the biases are floating around in your social computing users and in your social computing software.
A fair number of games and studies suggest that you can have fairly dramatic effects on the biases, at least in the short term. Long-term effects are less clear, though — how would we study that?
I ran out of battery so lost most of the last bit, but one notable element was a design claim that having a more diverse team leads to more diverse games and outputs. This rang true on its face, and has some support from our own experiences writing prompts for the Pensieve project; the team was largely white rich kids from the Northeast and the prompts reflected that, in ways that sometimes made users from different backgrounds sad. So, this seems like a pretty useful nugget to take away.
Now, Eric, on design and intervention, and design vs. design research. In particular, claims about design research: it tends to focus on situations with topical/theoretical potential; it embeds designers’ judgment, value, and biases; and the results hopefully speak back to the theory and topics chosen, broadening the scope of knowledge and possibilities, as well as perhaps improving or reflecting on design processes themselves.
He’s also advocating for a more risky approach and perspective on design, with the claim that we often are good at solving well-defined problems (“good grades”) but not so good at having ideas that might help us think about tough problems (“creative thinking”). Further, the harder the problem, the less we know about it.
Like Mary, Eric is talking to some extent about critical design, speculative prototyping that calls out assumptions, possibilities, and hypotheses. There’s a general critical design meme that you’re looking for strong opinions that doesn’t seem necessary (suppose I reflect on assumption X and come to conclude I’m okay with it), but the general goal is to look outside of the normal ways that we look at a situation.
Now we’re going through a process that Phoebe Sengers talks about for thinking about design (and research) spaces: figure out what the core metaphors and assumptions of the field are, look at what’s left out, and then try to invert the goals to focus on what’s left out and leave out what’s a core assumption. Here we’re talking about this in the context of telepresence: what would it mean to think about telepresence not for work and fidelity but for fun and experience. One bit is an interesting parallel between early causal telepresence robots and, say, FaceTime.
Our next step is to think about the core assumptions of social computing (“find friends and connect”), what’s left out (“familiar strangers”), and inverting (“designing technology that exposes and respects the familiar stranger relationship”). Again, an impact claim here, that designs like Jabberwocky inspired things like Foursquare (with evidence that this is true, which is cool).
I wonder what the ratio of ‘successful’ to ‘unsuccessful’ or ‘more interesting’ to ‘less interesting’ critical design projects is. We’re now going through a large series of designs and it makes me wonder how many other designs we’re not talking about. Of course, you can say the same thing about research papers… and in both cases it would be really nice to see a little more of the sausage being made.
The large number of designs is also reminding me of the CHI 2013 keynote. Here we’re looking to illustrate the idea that looking at other design cultures might be useful for us, but the connections between particular designs and the underlying concepts/points/ideas are often not so clear: how do we make sense of these as a group. There’s always a talk tension where you want to talk about lots of cool stuff, making the connections between them, and managing the audience capacity, and again, this is not specific to designs (you see it in, say, job talks sometimes).
Now a discussion around the value of amateurs, DIY culture, and the idea that innovations often happen when people cross over these boundaries ($1 to Ron Burt, I think). It’s not clear that this follows from the set of designs we’ve talked about, but it’s a plausible and reasonable place and one that I try to live in a fair amount myself. There are costs to this — learning time and increase risk of failure — but I think that’s part of our game.
More heuristics around critical design, more than I expected, so kind of a giant list here:
- Constraints (when is technology useful)
- Questioning progress (what negative outcomes and lost elements arise)
- Celebrate the noir/darkness (seek out unintended uses and effects)
- Misuse technology (hacking/repurposing tech and intentionally doing things the wrong way)
- Bend stereotypes (who are the ‘intended’ users)
- Blend contexts (perhaps mainly physical and digital)
- Be seamful (exploit the failure points of technology)
- Tactful contrarianness (confidence in the value of inversions)
- Embrace making problems (designs that cause or suggest issues, not resolve them)
- Make it painful (versus easy or useful to use),
- Read (not just papers), and
- Be an amateur (a lover of what you do).
While this guide is lacking in some areas, I hope that it provides enough tools for you to get started on making improvements to your critical design notes! This first talk was intended for a non-game design audience and served to give the goals of game design. Visit here php programmers and learn more tips on technology. The second talk focused on how to build a system in a way that serves your needs so that it’s easy to keep expanding it and possibly changing it around.
Mary Flanagan and Eric Paulos discuss critical thinking and how it can be applied to the world today. They start by discussing critical thinking, which has been defined in many different ways over the years, and how even how it is defined in one version is not exactly what is meant by critical thinking in all other versions. Also, you can get PureWL to learn some technical ways about the VPN. They then show examples of how critical thinking is not only being used on a university level but being used by corporations all around the world.
That’s really informative guide about notes of game design. Special thanks from pest control virginia beach.
I think that when it comes to development, whether it’s games or software, working with reliable specialists is essential. It’s great that companies like sloboda-studio.com are not that hard to find, and in that case, you can rely on a team that can provide you with an individual approach and take into account all the goals and needs of your business.
Games have become an integral part of our lives, offering us a delightful escape into virtual realms filled with adventure and excitement. Whether it’s immersive role-playing games, challenging puzzles, or thrilling multiplayer battles, games provide endless entertainment and engagement. With the rise of online gaming platforms, such as https://pticica.com/, players from around the world can connect and compete in thrilling competitions, fostering a sense of camaraderie and friendly competition. These games offer an immersive experience, transporting players into fantastical worlds where they can explore, strategize, and forge unforgettable memories.
Thanks Cornell team for sharing such a great informative content. How long have you been writing such a great content? Keep it up!
Please check: Dental in Scarborough
What about gambling? Maybe I missed it in the article, but I’m interested in learning more about this type of game. And how reliable is it if I want to make money in an online casino.
Many people are still skeptical about gambling and online casinos, so I’m not even surprised that this is rarely talked about, considering it something of a scam. Although I manage to make money in the casino from time to time. For example, Conquestador provides really cool conditions and a nice welcome bonus that will help you earn your first money faster.
I am so happy after finding this backlinks list
Don’t be skeptical about the use of game elements in the learning process. Regardless of the target audience for which you are creating an application, I highly recommend reading the article on link https://anyforsoft.com/blog/gamification-in-elearning/ . Simple methods like gamification can attract more customers.
Game design is pivotal in creating immersive and enjoyable gaming experiences. For enthusiasts of rhythm games, the innovative fnf mods online available for Friday Night Funkin’ exemplify creative game design. They introduce diverse musical challenges and genres, showcasing how design elements can significantly enhance gameplay and user experience
Mary Flanagan and Eric Paulos explore critical game design principles in their work on SoCS (Social and Critical Computing) with a focus on fostering meaningful interactions and societal reflections. Their notes delve into the intricate balance between entertainment and social impact, emphasizing the potential of games as tools for dialogue and change. Within this discourse, the 토토사이트 리뷰 underscores the importance of assessing the societal implications and ethical considerations inherent in game design, urging developers to engage responsibly with their creations and the communities they impact.
Mary Flanagan and Eric Paulos, in their critical examination of Social Computing Systems (SoCS), illuminate the intricate intersections of technology and society. Their analysis delves into the nuanced impacts of digital innovations, challenging conventional perspectives. Flanagan and Paulos scrutinize the socio-technical landscape with a keen eye, unraveling the complexities inherent in human-computer interactions. Through their lens, SoCS emerge not merely as tools but as dynamic agents shaping human behavior and societal structures. Their exploration invokes introspection, prompting us to question the implications of every toujeo insulin pen in the digital era.
Critical game design involves evaluating and refining the core elements that contribute to a game’s overall experience. It encompasses understanding the balance between gameplay mechanics, narrative, and user engagement. Effective game design ensures that players remain challenged yet entertained, creating a compelling and immersive experience. In a broader context, just as 무료스포츠중계 (free sports broadcasting) provides accessible and engaging content to audiences, critical game design aims to offer players an equally captivating and rewarding experience. By focusing on the nuances of player interaction and game dynamics, designers can create games that resonate with their audience and stand the test of time.
Games offer an exciting escape from the routine of daily life, bringing joy and competition to people of all ages. Whether it’s a board game, a video game, or a thrilling sports match, the sense of excitement and challenge is universal. In South Korea, 축구중계 or soccer broadcasting, is a highly popular form of entertainment, drawing fans together to support their favorite teams. The sense of unity and excitement in these games brings communities together, making the experience unforgettable.
다양한 주제의 발표에서 ‘나에게 이득이 될 만한 것’을 찾으라는 태도가 인상 깊습니다. 평소에는 전공이 다르면 관심을 덜 가졌는데, 더킹플러스카지노 이제는 더 적극적으로 관련성을 찾아 질문을 준비하는 습관을 들여야겠어요.
The top car on the market today seamlessly combines performance, luxury, and versatility. Known for its robust design, this vehicle is ideal for adventure enthusiasts and families alike. With its spacious interior and advanced safety features, it ensures a comfortable ride for all passengers. Additionally, the integration of UTV accessories enhances its functionality, allowing drivers to customize their vehicles for off-road experiences. Whether tackling rugged terrains or navigating urban streets, this top car proves to be the ultimate choice for those seeking style and capability in one package.
Blessing items are symbolic objects used in various cultures to bring good fortune, health, and positive energy. They often carry deep spiritual significance, serving as reminders of balance and harmony. A popular example is the yin and yang symbol, which represents the interconnectedness of opposites. The yin and yang meaning reflects the duality of life, such as light and dark, male and female, or good and bad, showing that both are necessary for equilibrium. Blessing items like amulets, charms, and crystals embody this concept, offering protection and encouraging individuals to find peace and stability in their lives.