by |

On Asking Questions and Academic Love

I remember my first forays into question-asking at the CS colloquium in my first semester.  John Riedl told me to have a question ready for every single talk and, if no one else has one, ask it, no matter how good you think it is. This was pretty scary for someone with a music ed undergrad from Ohio State and a fine, but professionally oriented, CS masters from James Madison. So I felt ill-prepared for deep thoughts on talks about phase transitions in the difficulty of 3-SAT problems or statistics questions for Bob Kraut.

But I made the questions, and I asked the questions, and as those who have seen me at conferences can attest, I continue to do so. I’m glad John made me do it; here’s why*.

First, paying enough attention to a talk to make a good question means that I’m actively engaging with the ideas and with the speaker. This, in turn, means I’m not checking e-mail, working on my own slides, making mildly amusing comments on Facebook, or other things that we regularly criticize our students for in the classroom that take us away from the moment and the speaker.

Second, thinking hard about topics, especially ones that aren’t in my comfort zone, can lead to new ideas. I try to go into talks (and papers) with a “what’s in this for me” attitude–what can I learn or use from this talk?  When I do that, almost any talk or topic is interesting, even if I have to do translation work to connect topic X to my own interests**.

Finally, questions are love in academia. I’ve had talks when I’ve gotten two questions, and although I try to tell myself it’s because I’m full of blinding insight, that statement is full of something else. Asking a question says “I cared enough about your work to think hard about it.” We can all use a little more love.***

So, spread the love. Pay some attention and ask some questions. It’s part of being in the community.

A couple of quick notes for new question askers. First, don’t make the question about you. It’s okay to ask hard questions^, and asking good questions can help you be more visible^^, but don’t ask a question just to demonstrate that you’re smart. We’re all smart. Second, don’t make the question about you. Some questions are thinly disguised opinion pieces and/or self-promotion, and we don’t need any more of those.  Third, don’t make the question about you. If you’re taking the ideas into your domain, help bring them back out for the speaker and the audience so they make sense.

On question style, be more like an interviewer than a lawyer. Lawyers often ask yes-no questions, leading questions, and questions where they already know the answer. Usually, those lead to boring answers. So do questions where the answer is likely to be about details that are in the paper but that (probably correctly) got left out of the talk for space^^^.

Instead, shoot for more open-ended questions that give the speaker room and context to breathe and be creative. I don’t have a lot of canned strategies for this, but folks with some humanities/critical/philosophical background often ask nice questions by bringing the topic up an abstraction level. For example, at a talk on how recommender interfaces change opinions, someone asked whether this was a good or bad thing, which was an awesome question that got at the heart of what recommender systems do. It can be fun, done with care, to call attention to an aspect of the topic that’s not focused on in the talk. In the HCI/CSCW world, asking about social implications or compelling applications of technology/systems papers is a common model, as is asking about technical or design implications of experimental or observational studies. Asking about how the ideas fit nearby, related domains or ideas can lead to nice chats. Finally, asking about unexpected things that happened during the study can lead to interesting insights.

Here’s hoping I ask fewer questions at CSCW next week because you pass this on to students and other folks who carry the torch. Thanks for reading and let everyone know if you have strategies (or alternate opinions) around good question-asking.

—

* A few other folks who have written about this, with extra detail and somewhat different takes, for folks who want to think more about question-asking goals and strategies:

** I really like dodging outside of my topic areas. Although there’s value in and pressure to be deep and a little narrow in academia, there’s also value in being broad and establishing intellectual trade routes.

*** Questions can lead to longer-term conversations later. My first encounter with Jofish Kaye and Janet Vertisi was asking a question at their CHI 2006 talk on personal archiving. Little did I know I’d be hanging out with them at Cornell shortly thereafter, and having gone, thought about their topic, and asked the question paved the way for natural interaction later.

^ Best done gently. I remember someone basically calling someone else a fraud at a machine learning conference once, which put a damper on things.

^^ Especially if you announce your name and institution, which should be a conference norm. At most talks most people won’t know most people, and it’s good for community to announce.

^^^ Methodology questions often have this flavor. If you have a deeper question that depends on method info, go for it, but conversations about big ideas are usually more fun than those about p-values, Krippendorph’s alphas, or algorithm parameters.

 

Associate Professor in Information Science at Cornell and rotating Program Officer in Cyber-Human Systems at NSF.

Published

Write a Comment

Comment

3,145 Comments

  1. Fantastic blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers? I’m planning to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you propose starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m completely overwhelmed .. Any suggestions? Many thanks! gravure-movie.com

  3. The article looks magnificent, but it would be beneficial if you can share more about the suchlike subjects in the future. Keep posting. NONA 189

  4. 소액결제 현금화란 바로 이 휴대폰 소액결제에 주어진 한도를 이용해 온라인에서 물품이나 모바일 상품권 등을 구매한 뒤, 일정 수수료를 제외하고 다시 판매하여 현금을 소액결제 현금화

  5. 소액결제 현금화란 바로 이 휴대폰 소액결제에 주어진 한도를 이용해 온라인에서 물품이나 모바일 상품권 등을 구매한 뒤, 일정 수수료를 제외하고 다시 판매하여 현금을 소액결제 현금화

  6. 의정부출장마사지 – 의정부 전역에 24시간 여성 전문 마사지사가 찾아가는 출장 홈타이 서비스! 아로마, 스포츠, 커플 마사지로 피로와 스트레스를 합리적 가격에 풀어 의정부출장마사지

  7. 유흥알바는 술집, 클럽, 노래방 등 유흥업소에서 하는 다양한 아르바이트를 통칭합니다. 주로 야간에 이뤄지며 룸알바, 밤알바, 여성알바 등 여러 이름으로 불립니다. 유흥알바

  10. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often. https://tapewrangler.com/

  11. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post. WANGI 889

  13. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! ANAKRAJA77

  14. Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. bhakti-sastri.com

  16. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work… flynnmarketinggroup.comom

  17. I just couldn’t leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts. alhutaibelectricco.com

  18. I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing. bookedparties.com

  19. I appreciate this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so interested in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. Your blog is really impressive. DEMON 189

  20. it was a wonderful chance to visit this kind of site and I am happy to know. thank you so much for giving us a chance to have this opportunity.. Pink salt recipe

  27. I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I Always prefer to read The Quality and glad I found this thing in you post. Thanks Blue salt trick for men

  30. 청주출장마사지 – 청주 전역에 24시간 여성 전문 마사지사가 찾아가는 출장 홈타이 서비스! 아로마, 스포츠, 커플 마사지로 피로와 스트레스를 합리적 가격에 풀어 청주출장마사지

  31. 수원출장마사지 – 수원 전역에 24시간 여성 전문 마사지사가 찾아가는 출장 홈타이 서비스! 아로마, 스포츠, 커플 마사지로 피로와 스트레스를 합리적 가격에 풀어 수원출장마사지

  32. Thanks for the blog filled with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for. Now my task has become as easy as ABC. gilletthistorical.com

  33. I just couldn’t leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts. Blue salt trick for men

  34. Your blog is too much amazing. I have found with ease what I was looking. Moreover, the content quality is awesome. Thanks for the nudge! TEKNO189

  36. Very informative post! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign. boostaro reviews

  37. Great job here on _______ I read a lot of blog posts, but I never heard a topic like this. I Love this topic you made about the blogger’s bucket list. Very resourceful. sculptra vs microneedling

  40. Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. Big thanks for the useful info. Gelatin trick reciipe

  41. 일산출장마사지 – 일산 전역에 24시간 여성 전문 마사지사가 찾아가는 출장 홈타이 서비스! 아로마, 스포츠, 커플 마사지로 피로와 스트레스를 합리적 가격에 풀어 일산출장마사지

  42. Yes, I am entirely agreed with this article, and I just want say that this article is very helpful and enlightening. I also have some precious piece of concerned info !!!!!!Thanks. Gelatin trick reciipe