In arXiv we are constantly considering new trends in submissions coming in and if and how they fit into our moderation guidelines. The discussion recently by arXiv staff and volunteer moderators has been about the trend for short works in journals and conference proceedings. Our current policy is not to accept very short works, generally three pages or less, even if they are are accepted or published elsewhere. Here is a snapshot of our current thinking.
What is of interest to arXiv?
While rapid communication of scientific research is key to our mission, we primarily support substantive self-contained research documents that are of archival interest. Details about our moderation guidelines are at https://arxiv.org/help/moderation
Do we make exceptions?
Yes, based on the moderators discretion of what is of plausible interest to readers. It is also true that occasionally submissions appear on arXiv that slip past our moderation process and perhaps should have been rejected, however once the paper is announced it cannot be removed.
What are some concerns with very short pieces?
Our goal is to provide readers with papers that are of high interest in each subject area daily mailing. But a proliferation of very short postings in various fields across arXiv would create considerable extra work for our volunteer moderators to determine if each posting is of sufficient content to be of interest to readers.
What about the future?
arXiv maintains an independent moderation process that continually evolves with changes in the scholarly publication ecosystem. We are also rebuilding our technical infrastructure to improve the user experience, the adaptability of the system, and the scalability of moderation. One consideration we have been discussing as part of the Next Generation arXiv is to label the type of content posted to arXiv. Rather than trying to fit research articles, PhD theses, conference proceedings, etc. into the same bucket, we could label them and then let readers choose what content they want to read. This may allow our future moderation policies to evolve to accept a broader array of content.
Jim Entwood
arXiv Operations Manager