NY State Integrated Pest Management Field Crops and Livestock Program
Reports, photos and samples have been pouring in with regards to dying soybeans from western and central NY counties. Some people report general chlorosis and wilting, and others are finding swaths of dead plants. The drought conditions experienced in some parts of the state this year may have lulled some of us into thinking that we might be spared from some of our typical soybean diseases. And, it’s true that foliar diseases have been nearly non-existent this season. But, some of our important soilborne diseases are now rearing their ugly heads, and some of us are scratching our heads to figure out which is which. Since many of these diseases tend to have similar general symptoms, especially early on, it’s important to get an accurate diagnosis to make any management decisions for both this season and future variety selections. Thus far, I have confirmed Phytophthora root and stem rot, northern stem canker and Fusarium wilt in a handful of fields, but these problems are likely more widespread and we’ll probably continue to see more samples.
Managing these soilborne diseases can be challenging, and requires an integrated approach. When a soilborne disease is identified in a field, you may need to implement multiple tactics, including resistant varieties, crop rotations, residue management, field drainage improvement, alternate weed host management, seed treatments and foliar fungicides where applicable. Below is more information on some of the diseases of concern identified, thus far, this season.
Phytophthora Root and Stem Rot
Phytophtora root and stem rot stem lesion extending up from the soil line (photo by Mike Hunter)
Phytophthora root and stem rot, caused by Phytophthora sojae is a complicated soilborne disease of economic concern in soybean production areas of NY. It has been confirmed in at least nine counties in NY, and it is likely more widespread throughout the state. As with most of the soilborne diseases, occurrence depends on favorable conditions, including cool and wet conditions and compacted soils at planting time. The disease is exacerbated by flooding of fields after seeding has occurred. The 2018 growing season has been ideal for this disease in some parts of the state, given our prolonged wet spring and recent heavy rain events causing saturation in some fields. The pathogen survives long-term in the soil as hardy oospores. These oospores germinate to produce sporangia that release the swimming zoospores which infect the soybean roots or are splashed up into the canopy. Infection of seedlings often results in damping off. Symptoms of infection of older plants include lesions beginning at the soil line and extending up the stem, yellow/chlorotic leaves, wilting, reduced vigor, reduction in root mass and death. We are currently seeing these symptoms in plants in various reproductive stages. Over 70 races of this pathogen exist, making management with resistant varieties challenging without knowing which races occur in a particular field. However, varieties with partial resistance (also called field tolerance), which adds some level of protection against all races, are available and highly recommended. Improving soil drainage, reducing compaction, utilizing seed treatments, genetic resistance, and crop rotation are good tools for managing Phytophthora root and stem rot.
Phytophthora stem rot internal symptoms (photo by Jeff Miller)
Phytophtora root and stem rot in a section of a field in Oneida County early August, 2018 (photo by Jeff Miller)
Northern Stem Canker
Northern stem canker inside stem (photo by Jaime Cummings)
Northern stem canker, caused by the fungus Diaporthe caulivora, is a disease of economic concern that was first identified and confirmed in NY in 2014. Since the initial confirmation, it has been discovered to be fairly widespread throughout many soybean production areas in NY, though usually only at moderately low incidences. We are starting to see it in western NY this year, and expect to find it more widespread as favorable weather conditions continue. The pathogen survives on infected soy residue, and infection often occurs during vegetative growth stages, but symptoms don’t appear until reproductive stages. Foliar symptoms include interveinal chlorosis, followed by necrosis, and is indistinguishable from the foliar symptoms of other soilborne diseases including sudden death syndrome and brown stem rot. Initially, small reddish-brown lesions appear, often near nodes on the lower stems, which expand into distinctive ‘cankers’ with slightly sunken, grayish-brown centers and reddish margins. Large cankers may girdle stems completely. Splitting stems longitudinally may reveal a browning discoloration of the vascular tissue and pith, often more pronounced near the nodes on the lower stems, similar to what is observed with brown stem rot. In severe cases with large cankers, the entire pith may be brownish-red. The disease reduces the number and size of seeds produced, and could result in yield losses of up to 50% in a severe epidemic. It is important to note that there are two forms of stem canker; 1) northern stem canker, and 2) southern stem canker. Southern stem canker has not been identified in NY. Each disease is caused by a different pathogen, and controlled by separate resistance genes. Because northern stem canker was dismissed as a disease of minor importance in the 1950s, most seed companies do not provide disease ratings specific for northern stem canker in their catalogs. Most ‘stem canker’ ratings in commercial seed catalogs are for southern stem canker (unless noted otherwise), which is a disease of great importance to many soybean production areas of the U.S., but have no relevance to northern stem canker resistance. Foliar fungicide applications for management have shown inconsistent results, and may not be cost effective. Tillage practices to bury infected residues and rotation with non-host crops, including small grains or corn, are recommended for highly infested fields if varieties with resistance specific to northern stem canker are not available.
Northern stem canker foliar symptoms of interveinal chlorosis and necrosis (photo by Jaime Cummings)
Northern stem canker lesions on stem (photo by Jaime Cummings)
Internal discoloration of vascular tissue of lower stems caused by Fusarium wilt (photo by Jaime Cummings)
Fusarium wilt, caused by a number of Fusarium species, is a fungal soilborne disease of concern in soybean production areas of NY, particularly in years with drought, like we are experiencing in 2018. Though it has only been confirmed in a few counties, it is likely much more widespread, but is difficult to diagnose or differentiate from other diseases or stresses. It’s easiest to rule out other diseases, like Phytophthora root and stem rot, northern stem canker, charcoal rot and brown stem rot to arrive at an accurate diagnosis. Infection is favored by cool temperatures and wet soils during early vegetative growth stages. Plants are infected during early vegetative stages, but symptoms appear later in the season during reproductive stages, and are exacerbated by hot, dry weather, when infected plants begin to wilt. In addition to wilting, symptoms include brown discoloration of the vascular system in the roots, crowns and stems, and foliage may become generally chlorotic and defoliation may occur. Sometimes, the general wilting and chlorosis are overlooked as heat stress, and the full extent of the disease in a field doesn’t become evident until many plants in a field die. Reducing soil compaction, delaying planting until soil temperatures are favorable for seed germination, crop rotation and seed treatments applied to high quality seed are good management practices for minimizing losses to Fusarium wilt.
Fusarium wilt in a field in Livingston County in early August 2018 (photo by Mike Stanyard)
Fusarium wilt in a field in Livingston County in 2018 (photo by Mike Stanyard)
There can be a lot of overlap in symptoms among many soilborne diseases of soybeans. Be sure to arrive at an accurate diagnosis before making any decisions. And, remember, when scouting and collecting samples for submission for diagnosis, the diagnosis you receive is only as good as the sample you submit. Be sure to collect whole plants, with roots, and ship them overnight to ensure they arrive in good condition. Information on how to submit specimens for diagnosis is available on the Cornell Plant Disease Diagnostic Clinic website http://plantclinic.cornell.edu/pddcforms/submissionform.pdf, and a submission form is available at http://plantclinic.cornell.edu/pddcforms/submissionform.pdf. And, for more information on soybean diseases in NY, please visit the soybean disease survey portion of fieldcrops.org (https://fieldcrops.cals.cornell.edu/soybeans/diseases-soybeans/soybean-disease-survey/).