You never know how you feel about the things that surround you daily until you’re taken away from them. Sometimes absence makes the heart grow fonder, and sometimes it makes you realize flaws you hadn’t seen before. I never thought I would actually start to appreciate the U.S. more when I went abroad.
It’s not that I’ve been here for a long time yet, and it’s not that I am homesick. So far, a week and a half has given me only a superficial first taste of the city called Barcelona, and the country called Spain. I can’t even begin to make generalizations about Spain because I sense that Barcelona is not quite representative of it, the same way New York is not representative of the United States. But I tend to notice that first impressions are very substantial—they are usually either exactly right or exactly the opposite of the truth.
My first impression, sadly enough, was that of a lack of surprise. Maybe I expected too much. Maybe nothing is shocking when you’ve seen and heard so much on television and in books, and had the opportunity to travel outside your hometown. But that is exactly what I fear. That there really is nothing more to exotic places than what we’ve already heard about them—except the un-exotic parts that make them just like “back home”. In a way, it’s comforting to know that people are people, and that not much differs from place to place when you get down to the core of life. But it’s awfully disappointing for a travelling romantic.
I thought I’d be surrounded by art. And in a way, I am. But the stunning Casa Batlló created by Gaudí is flanked by a modern hotel and a row of the same Chanel and other brand-name stores that you would see in any other large Western city. La Rambla, the crowd-drawing central street of food and nightlife has a fascinating maze of narrow alley-like streets branching off of it, with old grey buildings, cobble-stone roads and tiny Medieval-sized sidewalks. But after walking around for even ten minutes, you start to see the same “Pans & Company” sandwich place, “Desigual” clothing store, and “H&M” over and over. As my friend Jonathan called it, it’s simply “the same stuff in different packaging, with a European label.” Pans & Company is like Quizno’s or Subway, Desigual is like Hot Topic or Pacsun, and H&M is well, H&M. To be sure, it all has a bit of a different flavor. Fashion is quite different here—you will never ever find pajamas or sweatpants on a passerby, or even running sneakers, for that matter. North Face jackets or hooded sweatshirts are a major no-no. But essentially both Americans and Spaniards are eating the same sandwiches from chain restaurants, shopping for the same types of clothes, and listening to the same music. That was the most disappointing part—all the stores, bars and clubs play American music. I’ve heard about one Spanish song for every ten or fifteen American (or British) ones since I’ve been here.
But the bigger issue is this: In the modern, modernized world, nothing is sacred. A city is a city is a city, glorious as the place may be. Barcelona has the same number of independent film theatres as New York (about a handful, maybe 4). It has the same ballets and operas in its theatres, the same books in its bookstores, and the same magazines on its newsstands. They even hand out the same “AM” and “Metro” newspapers as they do in the subway in New York! For all the American pop culture they consume, though, the Spanish are not very receptive to American tourists. I’ve never looked at it from the defensive perspective before—I always shared in the “European” criticism of American culture, or lack thereof, as we like to say. I’ve found myself instinctively identifying myself as Russian rather than American when I am asked, and saying I’m from New York rather than “The United States”. But now I realize how much New York has. Rather than lamenting its membership to the United States, today I have understood that this is what made its existence possible. Such a city could not exist but in a country without a history. Barcelona does have culture, yes—but it is a vague pride in art and historical continuity thinly transposed on a blanket of same-old, same-old. New York may be ambiguous at first, but there is a locality and a groundedness to every piece of culture. We never had a “national culture” like Spain or Italy or France—we are fragmented, composed of the frontier dreams and hard work we are both proud of and embarrassed of at the same time. New York is a perfect hallmark of the land without a past; every neighborhood retains the character of the ethnicity it represents: the Arabic neighborhoods are Arabic, the Russian neighborhood is Russian, and the Chinese neighborhood is Chinese. They’re not just “American” neighborhoods with a few restaurants containing ethnic food. Because that idea does not exist. America is the conglomeration of many different cultures—but they’re able to keep their roots! (In New York, at least.) So I can go and eat Japanese food, and really experience a piece of Japanese culture. Then I can hop over to the Russian neighborhood and everything is different. It’s a mish-mosh of a mosaic, but it’s all very genuine. I have yet to witness a demonstration of what exactly is Spanish culture in the city of Barcelona—or even what Catalonian culture is. Barcelona (and Europe in general) may have contributed a lot to what we consider “culture” now, but it seems like it has lost that connection to what made it unique. Its contributions have been uprooted and spread across the world in the web of ideas and objects we call modernity. And in the meantime, it has become like everyone else. But New York is everyone, it’s not like everyone. (And as for unique contributions to the world, I remembered that we do have some: Broadway is a singular sensation, original to the U.S.)
I suppose I expected something better, if not bigger, than New York. Better in the sense of a more natural, historical, unified culture. But maybe such a thing does not exist. Maybe New York is as good as it gets in terms of centers of music, film, and art. I always knew how much I loved New York, but I thought that the European lifestyle suited me more than the American one. But now I realize that if “more of everything” is what I want, as I said in my first entry, then New York is the place to be.
Nevertheless, the “different packaging” here is interesting enough, and the flavors of the region are rather delightful. I think the age we live in has sucked the flavor out of most places, and perhaps the ones to see are the most remote ones, where the spice is most concentrated. But then again, perhaps Barcelona will still surprise me, and prove my first impression entirely wrong. Meanwhile, I do enjoy those small cobblestone streets and quaint cafés.